Scup-logo-80-90 Society for College and University Planning

Wednesday, April, 11, 2012

Does Traditional Publishing Hurt Scientific Progress?

If charges that traditional publishing slows research are true, what responsibility do research institutions have to encourage or provide alternative publishing methods? Is this another area of disruption where institutions could possible take something back?

Eighty five percent of published papers remain locked behind subscription pay walls, accessible only to those affiliated with universities and other large research institutions. But new journals that make everything they publish freely available are growing rapidly. And government efforts to make the results of all publicly funded scientific and medical research accessible to everyone are expanding, despite industry-backed legislative efforts to end them.

Backed into a corner, traditional publishers have launched a public relations campaign of sorts, attempting to justify their business practices by highlighting the value they add by overseeing peer review and editorial selection. Charging for access to their content, they argue, is the only way they can recoup their costs.

 

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, August, 26, 2010

Open Access Journals: Faculty Learn a New Trick

 A group called the Public Knowledge Project says its free online publishing software has allowed more than 5,000 new academic journals to be published. And there are lots of groups and projects like this one. In The Chronicle of Higher Education, Peter Schmidt writes:

 

In a world where subscriptions to some medical journals can cost more than $10,000 a year, and many colleges in developing countries cannot afford more than a handful of scholarly publications, publishing enabled by this kind of tool is plugging many academics into research and discourse as never before.

...

Open-access academic publishing has its limitations and drawbacks. It can be blocked by Internet filters. Its low cost makes the publication of inferior and unreliable journals much easier. And, in rendering scholarship freely available to anyone who can go online, it increases the risk that research in fields such as medicine will fall into the hands of people who might misuse it.

 

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

1330 Eisenhower Place | Ann Arbor, MI 48108 | phone: 734.669.3270 | fax: 734.661.0157 | email: info@scup.org

Copyright © Society for College and University Planning
All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Site Map